Medical Services | Health Information | Appointments | Education and Research | Jobs | About

Connect with an expert

Nutrition-wise blog

With Mayo Clinic nutritionists Jennifer Nelson, M.S., R.D. and Katherine Zeratsky, R.D.
Back to posting index
May 28, 2008
Extra pounds fuel for thought
20 comments posted
Read comments | Post a comment
By Jennifer Nelson, M.S., R.D. and Katherine Zeratsky, R.D.

A physician friend of mine just routed an article to me from a recent Lancet, a medical journal. In it, the authors suggest that obese people contribute more than their fair share to demands for world oil and to the food shortage. Oh, no, here we go again — another dig at those battling the bulge.

In their short commentary, the authors note that heavy folks eat about 20 percent more calories than leaner people, and that they prefer to drive to the market. Therefore, obese people use more gasoline to move those extra pounds.

Hmmm. Although I agree with the physics, at first reading it seemed a bit far fetched. Yes those of us who are struggling with weight do consume more calories, and it's true that we need to walk more. Cars use gas. Tractors use gas to help raise crops. Crops feed people — and now are being converted to ethanol to feed the tank. Therefore fuel for people and for cars is becoming in short supply — and more costly.

So — those extra pounds might be at the root of our current fuel (food and oil) crisis? It's gotten me thinking. In my commitment to becoming "greener" (and leaner) this will become one more reason for me to buy local, cut back on the extra helpings, and walk more. I'm going to do my part and help resolve the global fuel problem.

What do you think?

- Jennifer

20 comments posted
Read comments | Post a comment
Back to posting index
July 24, 2008 2:15 p.m.
While the idea that overweight people are contributing to global warming by driving back and forth to the supermarket is absurd, this article does obliquely hint at a real issue. Eating local is a great way to help with the fuel crisis. Most of our groceries travel great distances to reach us. Eating a diet of locally farmed foods, and concentrating on eating seasonal fruits and vegetables is a great way to help the environment and ourselves.
- Nou
July 9, 2008 11:07 a.m.
This article is ridiculous. I know of all the great benefits of maintaining a healthy weight but come on!!! They can't blame it on the overweight folks. I have seen thin people driving to the 7 eleven around the corner, and what about all the Hummers and SUVS??? If we are talking about food shortage or the extra food overweight people consume, I say hot dog eating contest or any kind of eating contest should be banned and bulimic people should be at blame too, they are not only wasting food but also water everytime they flush after throwing up.
- No name given
June 28, 2008 4:31 p.m.
The writers of that piece in that medical journal are utterly insane. Obesity is definitely a problem. Just as much of a problem is the callousness and insensitivity that permeates our culture. I'm looking to lose weight not just for myself, but to avoid dealing with the bull...hockey that pours out of some people's mouths whenever they feel the need to comment on an overweight person. Whomever these writers are, they're not sensible people proposing a sensible solution. They're punks.
- Brian
June 18, 2008 1:19 p.m.
Who ever wrote this knows little about nutrition and even less about the effects of poverty and food insecurity on body weight. Yes food insecurity is one cause of obesity! Maybe the real fattys the greedy folks who need to haul thier tiny little bodies around in Hummers and consume foods that take excessive resources to produce are to share the blame. This is just "adding insult to injury" how could anyone be so fatheaded?
- Bernadette
June 18, 2008 11:41 a.m.
I think the problem is that Americans of all shapes and sizes are consumption monsters... We waste so much food, gasoline, electricity, and generate so much trash. While I agree that overeating is a waste of resources, it is unfair to blame one group of people for a problem that an entire country participates in. People who are overweight can be identified as wasters because you can see the extra pounds. Millions of thin people waste resources as well.
- No name given
June 18, 2008 8:23 a.m.
I am so tired of people who are so rude and callous toward overweight people. I used to be slim and trim. I was considered pretty and shapely. I have gained over 70# in the last 2 years, have lost about 20# in the last 2 years. I have diabetes now and fibromyalgia. I am totally defeated by my weight and am well aware of how others see me. I have been humilated by relatives because of their crude and rude remarks. Now, I am to blame for the gas problem. Well, here is one fat lady that you can't blame!! I no longer leave my home because I don't want to seen this way. I don't go to see family,go to the store, or out to eat. I am watching what I eat but with the meds I take it seems like a loosing battle. I am defeated, I give up, I am done!! Next, we will be imprisoned for being fat!
- Diane
June 17, 2008 10:31 p.m.
I think it's true. And you have the right idea. I've thought about it many times also. I need to put the good ideas to use.
- No name given
June 14, 2008 12:57 a.m.
I think you have a great idea. I've thought about what you are saying many times.. you hit the nail on the head. I think a lot of us have this idea but it's just a matter of us putting our ideas and wishes to use.
- Rachel
June 13, 2008 1:04 p.m.
please!!! keep your articles away from ridiculous conjecture! your physician friend sounds a very prejudiced person. this turned me right off!
- dana
June 11, 2008 10:54 a.m.
For many years The AAA has been advising drivers to "lighten your load" as a way to improve your gas mileage. I can say from experience that it makes a difference. In the last year my husband and I have lost a combined total of about 100 lbs. and we have noticed a difference in how much gas we use on long trips. This shouldn't be about blaming others. We can all look for ways to make positive changes in our own lives. If protecting the environment motivates you to drop the extra pounds and do more walking, great! You'll also save money and be healthier for it.
- Lilly
Post a comment
COMMENTS PAGE
1 2

NUTRITION-WISE


Nov 20, 2008